.RS - Redovan sex se nastavlja, ovaj put sa developerske strane

[MorenoArdohain]

To mi nije jasno, na samom sajtu RNIDS pise da ce .YU domeni vaziti do 30. septembra 2009?

[torbica]

Originalno napisao MorenoArdohain

To mi nije jasno, na samom sajtu RNIDS pise da ce .YU domeni vaziti do 30. septembra 2009?

kome vise verujes?
hoces opkladu?

[valeksic]

Originalno napisao Peca

jel mogu da pitam ovde - ko je odredio rok da se .yu ugasi ovako rano?
kazem rano jer negde procitah da je SSSR-ov TLD bio aktivan vise od jedne decenije [a mozda je i jos aktivan?]
i ima li ikakvih sansi da se taj rok prolongira?

Minutes for Special Meeting of the ICANN Board of Directors
11 September 2007


Delegation of the .ME ( Montenegro) Domain
Delegation of the .RS ( Serbia) Domain
Redelegation of the .YU (former Yugoslavia) Domain

Kim Davies advised that the delegation of .ME ( Montenegro) and .RS ( Serbia) and the redelegation of .YU ( Yugoslavia) were interrelated. At the time that Serbia and Montenegro became new countries, the ISO 3166-1list was altered to give the two countries individual codes .RS and .ME respectively. To date, the countries covered have been using the .YU domain. The YU code is no longer in the ISO 3166-1 list and has been replaced with .ME and .RS and as such should be decommissioned in a responsible way. The transition plan from .YU to .RS and .ME involves an MOU between the two entities and would see that .YU is assigned to the proposed .RS sponsoring organization, which is effectively the same operator as today. They would act as caretaker for .YU for two years to allow for a stable transition. ICANN’s proposed resolution language is consistent with this plan however a three-year transition period is proposed to allow for contingencies. The proposed resolutions support the two new delegations and acknowledge the two parties involved in de-commissioning of the .YU domain, and state it is to be retired in three years time.

In addition to explaining the ICANN evaluation of the delegation applications, the board was also advised of last-minute correspondence IANA had received in relation to the delegation of the .ME domain.

Steve Goldstein asked if there is any provision in the agreement to restrict new registrations in .YU. Kim Davies advised that he would have to check to be certain, but as soon as new registrations are allowed in .RS and .ME it was his understanding that it would not be possible to register new domains in .YU.

Steve Goldstein asked why the preference for a three-year transition rather than two. Kim Davies advised they didn’t want to propose something that was too aggressive. The applicants had proposed a two-year transition period, but the Board could consider a different length.

The Chair proposed that the language in the resolution could be changed to be up to and no more than three years.

Steve Crocker acknowledged that some transitions have taken a long time. An additional suggestion would be to ask for regular reports with metrics measuring progress towards the outcome.

Kim Davies noted that the resolution proposed does suggest that the .YU registry report every 6 months to ICANN Staff on progress. The proposed resolution also makes it clear the domain must be removed no later than 2010, which was considered a responsible timeframe that was neither too aggressive, nor unnecessarily prolonged. If the community felt it could transition quicker there is nothing to stop that from happening.

Paul Twomey suggested that the wording be slightly amended asking that they report progress against appropriate metrics.

There were no objections to the suggested amendments.

Dave Wodelet asked if it mattered if they take till 2008, 2009 or even 2010 and the Chair responded that we do want a certain end date.

Kim Davies advised that there is no strong precedent for how long transition will take from one to the other. There have only been a small number of transitions of country codes in the history of ccTLDs. In trying to determine what they considered a reasonable timeframe for transition the closest comparable situation that IANA was aware of is when telephone-numbering systems change. These transitions generally take place in one-to-two years.

The Chair noted that the language proposed by Paul Twomey seems acceptable, an alternative to an extra year would be to stick with two years to 2009 and if the party needs more time they could come back and explain why, which may be the best option. Putting in a two-year timeframe provides them with leverage to help their community to promptly perform the transition. The Chair recommended the alternative on the basis it was made clear to them that if they have a problem with two years they can come back with an explanation to ICANN as to why they need more time.

Susan Crawford noted that she understands the direction and appreciates the conservative approach, but asked what mechanism should be used if the transition moves too slowly.

The Chair reflected that if they come back and have a reasonable explanation, then this should be okay. He believed you would help them with a shorter deadline as they can point to that as a mandate to move ahead and transition to other the domain.

Janis Karklins noted that human nature suggests they will take as much time as they are given for transitioning. He suggested that the resolution should include a point that ICANN Staff should keep the Board informed of the progress of the transition.

In summation, the Chair suggested that the Board approves all three requests, and that ICANN Staff is expected to keep the Board informed on the retirement of .YU domain. Paul Twomey added that they communicate according to appropriate metrics.

Steve Goldstein moved and Vanda Scartezini seconded the following resolution:

Delegation of .ME

Whereas, the .ME top-level domain is the designated country-code for

Montenegro ,

Whereas, ICANN has received a request for delegation of .ME to the Government of Montenegro,

Whereas, ICANN has reviewed the request, and has determined that the proposed delegation would be in the best interest of the local and global Internet communities,

Resolved (07.75), that the proposed delegation of the .ME domain to the Government of Montenegro is approved.

Delegation of .RS

Whereas, the .RS top-level domain is the designated country-code for Serbia,

Whereas, ICANN has received a request for delegation of .RS to the Serbian National Register of Internet Domain Names,

Whereas, ICANN has reviewed the request, and has determined that the proposed delegation would be in the best interest of the local and global Internet communities,

Resolved (07.76), that the proposed delegation of the .RS domain to the Serbian National Register of Internet Domain Names is approved.

Redelegation of .YU

Whereas, the .YU top-level domain is currently used by the citizens of both Serbia and Montenegro,

Whereas, ICANN has delegated the .RS domain for use in Serbia, and the .ME domain for use in Montenegro,

Whereas, the ISO 3166-1 standard has removed the “YU” code, and the ISO 3166 Maintenance Agency recommends its use be discontinued,

Whereas, ICANN is not responsible for deciding what is or is not a country, and adheres to the ISO 3166-1 standard for guidance on when to add, modify and remove country-code top-level domains,

Whereas, there is a transition plan to move registrations in .YU to the new domains .RS and .ME, with the operator of .RS acting as the temporary caretaker of .YU until the transition is complete,

Resolved (07.77), that the .YU domain be redelegated to the Serbian National Registry of Internet Domain Names in a temporary caretaker capacity.

Resolved (07.78), that the Serbian National Registry of Internet Domain Names be instructed to report their progress on decommissioning the .YU domain every six months to ICANN against a relevant set of metrics.

Resolved (07.79), that the Serbian National Registry of Internet Domain Names, and the Government of Montenegro, work to complete the transition from the .YU domain to the .RS and .ME domains, so that it may be removed from the DNS root zone no later than 30 September 2009.

A voice vote was taken of all Board Members present and all three motions were approved by a vote of all members present 13-0, with one abstention from Peter Dengate Thrush.

Peter Dengate Thrush explained that his reservation was associated with his belief that such policy decisions concerning delegation should rest with the ccNSO as specifically provided under the bylaws. He noted that he has raised this issue on a number of occasions suggesting that this matter should be referred to the ccNSO but to no avail.

The Chair noted that these practices have been in existence prior to the formation of the ccNSO, and that if policy is required in this area that the ccNSO work on a policy proposal, that might be properly considered.


http://www.iana.org/reports/2007/rs-...11sep2007.html

[smarkovic]

@Peca @Markok
O trajanju tranzicije za .yu domen odlučio je UO ICANN ovom odlukom iz septembra 2007:

http://www.iana.org/reports/2007/rs-...11sep2007.html

"Resolved (07.79), that the Serbian National Registry of Internet Domain Names, and the Government of Montenegro, work to complete the transition from the .YU domain to the .RS and .ME domains, so that it may be removed from the DNS root zone no later than 30 September 2009."

Takođe, iz zapisnika sa sednice UO ICANN vidi se da postoji prostor za produženje ovog roka, ukoliko se utvrdi da je to potrebno:

http://www.icann.org/en/minutes/prel...rt-11sep07.htm

Skupština RNIDS je jednom od svojih odluka iz oktobra 2007. obavezala UO da u saradnji sa ICANN učini sve da se ovaj rok produži (strana 4):

http://www.rnids.rs/files/list0034.pdf

Ja upravo radim na konačnom izveštaju RNIDS o tranziciji .yu domena za ICANN i u njemu će biti predloženo da se rok za tranziciju dodatno produži. Koliko vremena ćemo eventualno dobiti (i da li ćemo uopšte dobiti) niko ne može pouzdano da zna u ovom trenutku. Ipak, na osnovu dosadašnjeg iskustva sa ICANN jasno je da ICANN neće tolerisati produžavanje na "neograničeni" rok, ali mi deluje realno moguće da dobijemo produženje u opsegu od 6-24 meseca. Mada, kao što sam već rekao, mogu da odluče i da se drže prvobitnog roka, pa da brišu .yu zonu posle 30.09. ove godine.

Imajući u vidu ovo što sam rekao, priče koje priča Torbica su čista nagađanja i klađenje sa njim ti je čista lutrija

Što se tiče .su domena, on je u istom statusu kao i .yu (Being Phased Out):

http://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/su.html

i Rusi uveliko vode pregovore sa ICANN o načinu trajnog zatvaranja .su registra.

Inače, osnovna premisa ICANN koja stoji iza potrebe da se registri zemalja koje ne postoje uklanjaju sa Interneta otprilike bi mogla da se opiše na sledeći način (pošto nije precizno kodifikovana):

Ako se prilikom odlučivanja o tome ko može da ima nacionalni domen konsultuje ISO 3166 lista država (saglasno RFC 1591), onda se mora održati usklađenost sa tom listom; jer ako se odstupi od usklađenosti sa ISO 3166 listom, onda čemu uopšte pozivanje na tu listu od početka.

Drugim rečima, pozicija ICANN je da bi trenutni režim dodele nacionalnih TLD (baziran na RFC 1591) bio doveden u pitanje, ako bi se Rusiji/Srbiji/bilo kome dozvolilo da aktivno koristi TLD nepostojeće države u neodređenom vremenskom periodu.

Sve dok se u okviru ICANN ne postigne saglasnost o tome da režim otvaranja nacionalnih domena, uspostavljen RFC 1591, treba zameniti nečim drugim, imaćemo situaciju kakva je sada.

Pozdrav,
Sloba

[torbica]

Originalno napisao smarkovic

Ja upravo radim na konačnom izveštaju RNIDS o tranziciji .yu domena za ICANN i u njemu će biti predloženo da se rok za tranziciju dodatno produži. Koliko vremena ćemo eventualno dobiti (i da li ćemo uopšte dobiti) niko ne može pouzdano da zna u ovom trenutku. Ipak, na osnovu dosadašnjeg iskustva sa ICANN jasno je da ICANN neće tolerisati produžavanje na "neograničeni" rok, ali mi deluje realno moguće da dobijemo produženje u opsegu od 6-24 meseca. Mada, kao što sam već rekao, mogu da odluče i da se drže prvobitnog roka, pa da brišu .yu zonu posle 30.09. ove godine.

Imajući u vidu ovo što sam rekao, priče koje priča Torbica su čista nagađanja i klađenje sa njim ti je čista lutrija

Cobe je kao i obicno skroman
Primam opklade, ja kazem da ce rok da se produzi, Cobe je superstar

[Markok]

Ne sumnjam da se trazi nacin da se zatvori .su domen ali ipak moram da primetim da na www.nic.ru i dalje prodaju nove .su sto sugerise da mozda i nemaju nameru da i stvarno zatvare taj domen i da zele da prolongiraju zatvaranje do beskonacnosti. Ne znam, samo mi tako izgleda, i traje vec dvadeset godina.

[MorenoArdohain]

Rad'te sta oc'te, samo mi produzite .yu na jos godinu dana!

[Nemanja Avramović]

Uloži neku kintu, da bude zanimljivije

[torbica]

Originalno napisao Nemanja Avramović

Uloži neku kintu, da bude zanimljivije

100.000 dinara na produzenje

[Markok]

Jedan moj prijatelj ima prilicno ozbiljan problem. Prodaje neki softver cija se aktivacija vrsi preko web servisa koji je na co.yu domenu. On ne moze da povuce nazad iz prodaje ono sto se tamo vec nalazi + korisnici imaju pravo na vise od jedne aktivacije.

Jedini drugi kontakt naveden na softveru je telefonski broj. Kada ugasite co.yu covek ce se pretvoriti u telefonsku sekretaricu.